A Parenting Dilemma

Wednesday, November 12, 2008 3:01:29 PM (Eastern Standard Time, UTC-05:00)

Adam, at 27 months old, is, to my mind, getting old enough to not be using a sippy cup any longer. He drinks out of a regular "big boy" cup just fine. He holds the cup just fine. The problem? Every single meal in which he has a regular cup -- no lid -- he spills it. Usually it's inattentiveness -- he's only two, he drinks from his cup, puts it down next to his elbow, then reaches for something and BAM! Milk is everywhere. But often, it's willful disobedience -- he dumps it directly into his lap. Then laughs. Or pours it onto his placemat (and everything else) and draws in it. Then laughs. Or flails his arms and hands around and knocks it over. Then laughs. Or splatters it on the table, floor, chair and window. And, yes, then laughs.

Comparisons are odious. Mark took to drinking out of an open "big boy" cup just fine, and we didn't have this problem, so I have no previous experience on which to base this.

Do I:
* Go back to a sippy cup and pretend he's still a baby?
* Clean up spills every meal and watch the steam come out of my ears, nose and even eye sockets?
* Use the cups with the built-in straw (you can use the milk coming out of the straw to "color" on your placemat, too, it turns out)?
* Start giving him a bottle?

What suggstions do you have as "rewards" for times he doesn't spill his milk/water? Once again, this is mostly to deal with the intentional spills, not the accidents, which will get better as he gets older.

Suggestions that yield actual results might win you some kind of prize... stay tuned.

Wednesday, November 12, 2008 8:43:01 PM (Eastern Standard Time, UTC-05:00)
I make our girls clean up their own messes, whether it was intentional or an accident. I simply state "You made a mess so here is a towel for you to clean it up. It is your responsibility." Of course, I ended up cleaning it up better afterwards when they aren't looking, but perhaps he will get sick of cleaning up his own messes. Just an idea.

Also, if you let him choose his cup, does he choose the regular cup or a sippy cup? If you make him clean up his messes, perhaps you can let him choose which cup. The power of being resposible for your choices. I did this with Avery and then bought some princess big girl cups to sweeten the pot:) She could still choose, but she wanted those cool cups. I don't know if this helps, but there's my two cents. Good luck.
Wednesday, November 12, 2008 9:59:38 PM (Eastern Standard Time, UTC-05:00)
I was about to say the same things.

Or you could be my in-laws, who still give my daughter a sippy cup at their house at SIX YEARS OLD. Their excuse is that they don't have any other kid-sized cups, but come on ... Poor kid has to suck till her cheeks cave in just to get enough out of the spout.
Wednesday, November 12, 2008 11:29:19 PM (Eastern Standard Time, UTC-05:00)
Hehe, my little "angel" doesn't dooooooo those sorts of things...hahahaha! No actually she's at the "dropping food from her high chair intentionally to see what mommy does" stage.

As soon as you said "willful disobedience" I knew what I would do. Me? I'd spank.

Other tips though...I'm all about the "clean up your mess" bit. And if he's into pouring milk in his lap, let him sit in his milky pants the rest of the day. Ew! No fun. Does this mean I'm going to be a mean mommy?!
Wednesday, November 12, 2008 11:40:57 PM (Eastern Standard Time, UTC-05:00)
I love the "pick out your cup" idea! It's setting him up to succeed. Maybe you could even use it as an incentive, like "If you are careful with this cup at lunch, we can go to Target and get you any cup you want!" And then have a consequence in place if he disobeys and isn't careful with his new cup. (like cleaning up his mess, or a spanking, or using the baby cup the rest of the meal...etc)

My wheels are turning here can you tell? I love thinking about how I'll actually cross these bridges when they come to me. Let me know how it goes!
Thursday, November 13, 2008 5:31:31 AM (Eastern Standard Time, UTC-05:00)
Cage/hamster bottle.

Um, I think I know why I got to sweep up rotten apples as my main job at the family's preschool.
Saturday, November 15, 2008 11:32:57 AM (Eastern Standard Time, UTC-05:00)
As a non-parent, I'm totally qualified to respond to this;) I think that having Adam clean his mess up and give him an award for helping, like picking his own cup sounds like a good idea. However, if that doesn't work: a bowl on the floor works just fine for our cats!!
Name
E-mail
Home page

Comment (HTML not allowed)  

Enter the code shown (prevents robots):